Skip to content

Case study

Unit substation failure investigation — medium-voltage service entrance

A unit substation fault traced to how its secondary conductors were installed, with later damage to the transformer identified as a separate cause.

British Columbia · Forensic engineering · Electrical failure

We were retained to determine why a medium-voltage unit substation failed, and why its transformer could not be returned to service afterwards.

Challenge

The unit substation was the building's service entrance. A fault and fire in its secondary compartment took the building off supply. By the time the transformer reached a repair shop it had a second problem that the fault did not explain. The two had to be separated: what caused the failure, and what caused the transformer to be written off.

Approach

  • Examined the failed equipment, the recovered conductors and the arcing damage
  • Compared the installation against the shop drawings and against photographs taken before the failure
  • Measured the recovered cable and reconstructed the installed bend radius from photographs
  • Attended the transformer teardown and reviewed the insulation test results

Findings

The fault started at a conductor bend. The secondary conductors were installed with a bend radius well inside the cable manufacturer's minimum and the figure given in IEEE 1185, and one rested against a sharp edge of the enclosure. The Canadian Electrical Code requires bends large enough that the insulation is not damaged.

Operating vibration did the rest. Normal transformer vibration wore the insulation where it was strained and in contact with steel, until the conductor arced to the grounded enclosure and the fault spread across all phases.

The transformer was lost after the fault, not in it. Its insulating fluid was drained following the failure and the core and coils were left exposed to damp air. Some insulation tests passed, but insulation power factor was well above the acceptance value. We attributed this to moisture absorbed by the cellulose insulation, weighed an alternative explanation offered by the repair shop, and treated it as a contributing factor.

Why this matters

An installation defect and a handling decision made after a failure are separate causes with separate responsible parties. A causation report that keeps them apart lets each be dealt with on its own evidence.

Services applied

Forensic engineering and loss consulting · Forensic electrical engineering · Electrical engineering

Insurance and legal · All work

Talk to us about a claim

More work

Talk to us about your project

Send us the scope and the constraints. We will tell you plainly whether we are the right firm for it — and if we are not, we will say so.