Abbotsford, BC · Forensic engineering · Insurance claim
We were retained on an insurance claim to determine the root cause of repeated equipment failures at a large 24.9 kV campus facility, after ten months of recurring losses.
Challenge
Variable-frequency drives were failing repeatedly following utility outages and transfer to a 500 kVA standby generator, against a 2,000 kVA / 24.9 kV service serving a harmonic-rich, VFD-heavy load.
The failure mode was consistent: metal-oxide varistors on the drive PCBs failing as sacrificial elements, with associated heat damage. That consistency pointed to a system-level electrical cause rather than isolated component defects — but an insurer needs a technically sound root cause and a quantified basis for the loss, not a plausible theory.
Approach
- Analysed point-of-common-coupling power quality logs — voltage and current harmonics, THD and total demand distortion — against IEEE 519 limits
- Investigated harmonic resonance and switching transients associated with the site's static power-factor-correction capacitor bank as a candidate amplifier of the distortion
- Quantified the standby generator's contribution to distortion using source-impedance analysis
Findings
Root cause: excessive harmonic distortion with no harmonic mitigation designed into the facility. Site levels exceeded the IEEE 519 limits of 8.0% THD and 12% TDD at the point of common coupling.
The generator was the amplifier. On standby power, voltage THD reached approximately 300% of nominal. The generator's 18–20% impedance, against the transformer's 5.75%, amplified distortion three- to four-fold and drove transient voltages high enough to destroy the drives' sacrificial MOVs.
The power-factor-correction bank was investigated and excluded. Switched capacitors can form a parallel resonant circuit with supply transformer inductance and amplify specific harmonics, which made the bank a prime suspect. We examined it as a detuned capacitor bank of 25 kVAR switched steps, each with a reactor tuned below the fifth harmonic, and inspected for the capacitor damage that typically accompanies resonance. Logs captured with the bank energised and de-energised showed consistent harmonic content — indicating the static PFC was not the primary driver, though transient resonance remained a contributing factor.
Excluding a plausible cause with evidence is as much of the work as identifying the actual one. An insurer's position has to survive challenge.
Why this matters beyond the claim
Facilities with heavy VFD loads and undersized or high-impedance standby generation are exposed to this failure mode by design, not by accident. The generator that exists to protect the facility is the thing destroying the drives, and it only happens during outages — which is exactly when nobody is measuring.
Services applied
Forensic engineering and loss consulting · Forensic electrical engineering · Power quality
