British Columbia · Forensic engineering · Water damage
We were retained to identify the cause of a flood that ran unattended in a multi-unit residential building and damaged several floors.
Challenge
The water came from a plumbing fixture in one suite: a faucet left open over a closed drain. The fixture had an overflow. The question was whether the overflow should have prevented the damage, and so whether the fixture, its supply or its installation carried any of the cause.
Approach
- Site review of the source fixture, with the overflow openings measured
- Comparison of the installed fixture against the manufacturer's specification and the reviewed shop drawing
- Review of the building and plumbing codes and the product standards the fixture was listed to
- Flow calculation of the overflow's capacity against the rated flow of the faucet
Findings
The installed overflow was smaller than the documents showed. Its free area was well below both the specification and the shop drawing.
It could not pass the faucet's flow. Calculation showed the overflow could discharge only part of the faucet's rated flow.
No code required it to. Neither the building code nor the plumbing code requires an overflow on this type of fixture, and the product standard treats one as a mitigation feature, not a drain for continuous unattended flow.
The cause was the open faucet over a closed drain. The undersized overflow was documented as a discrepancy, not as the cause.
Why this matters
A discrepancy between the product installed and the product reviewed is easy to mistake for the cause of a loss. Measuring it, calculating what it could have done, and checking what the code required of it kept the causation finding on the event that produced the water.
Services applied
Forensic engineering and loss consulting · Mechanical engineering
